Welcome to

Greek Island Diner

Homey restaurant serving unpretentious American fare, breakfast & a few Mediterranean options.


Planning an event can be time consuming and stressful, but it doesn’t have to be. With Greek Island Diner catering service, your event is sure to go off without a hitch. We offer a huge selection of food to treat your guests to. From salads and seafood dishes to beef and Greek pasta dishes, we offer items everyone will love. We make it easy for you to offer delicious food for any event, no matter how many guests you have. 
 
Continue to browse our site to learn what our catering menu offers and what you could be eating at your next event!
Tasty Menu

Specials Menu Items

Greek Island Sandwich Specialties

Chicken Souvlaki (Marinated)$ 7.95 - $ 10.95

Regular: $ 7.95 | With Fries: $ 10.95

Pork Souvlaki (Marinated)$ 7.95 - $ 10.95

Regular: $ 7.95 | With Fries: $ 10.95

*Filet Mignon Souvlaki (Marinated)$ 10.95 - $ 13.95

Regular: $ 10.95 | With Fries: $ 13.95

Gyros$ 7.95 - $ 10.95

Regular: $ 7.95 | With Fries: $ 10.95

Chicken Gyro$ 7.95 - $ 10.95

Regular: $ 7.95 | With Fries: $ 10.95

Catering Greek Island Specialties

Spinach Pie$ 43.95 - $ 84.95

Half Tray: $ 43.95 | Full Tray: $ 84.95

Cheese Pie$ 43.95 - $ 84.95

Half Tray: $ 43.95 | Full Tray: $ 84.95

Greek Style Stuffed Chicken$ 59.95 - $ 109.95

Half Tray: $ 59.95 | Full Tray: $ 109.95

Spartan Pasta$ 54.95 - $ 102.95

Add Chicken or Shrimp for an additional charge
Half Tray: $ 54.95 | Full Tray: $ 102.95

Beef & Lamb or Chicken Gyro$ 59.95 - $ 109.95

Half Tray: $ 59.95 | Full Tray: $ 109.95
Testimonial

Our happy customers

  • 5 star ratingMy absolute favorite diner! The staff is so great, they make the best omelettes, the food is always tasty and... read more

    Sammy R. Avatar
    Sammy R.
    2/04/2018

    5 star ratingSolid food, large menu, generous servings, very quick service. They take cards & are a 15 min drive from Brookhaven... read more

    MineralPhysics U. Avatar
    MineralPhysics U.
    8/13/2017

    5 star ratingNew favorite place. Best gluten free menu and if it's not on the menu they will make you whatever you... read more

    Phyllis K. Avatar
    Phyllis K.
    7/15/2017
  • 5 star ratingBeen to this Diner a few times, food was great, atmosphere was friendly, prices very affordable. Waitress we had was... read more

    Rocker S. Avatar
    Rocker S.
    8/17/2018

    5 star ratingBest dinner in north fork area. I come from Freeport Nassau county , and I haven't been to a diner... read more

    Larry A. Avatar
    Larry A.
    9/02/2017

    5 star ratingThe staff is so friendly and attentive. This place has amazing authentic Greek food. The portions are large and always... read more

    Kristina M. Avatar
    Kristina M.
    6/29/2016
  • 5 star ratingAlways a pleasure eating here. The staff is extremely friendly and the food is always delicious. Highly recommended for breakfast,... read more

    Ken M. Avatar
    Ken M.
    10/28/2017

    5 star ratingI have been coming here for years, at least once a week, sometimes twice...It started with just breakfast on Sunday... read more

    Mark F. Avatar
    Mark F.
    1/08/2017

    5 star ratingThe best!  We catered from them , short notice and all was accommodated and delicious!
    We have catered from them...
    read more

    Alice K. Avatar
    Alice K.
    5/21/2018
  • 5 star ratingHad breakfast there this morning. Potato pancakes were awesome! (Not on the menu-but they will make them if you ask).... read more

    Michele W. Avatar
    Michele W.
    3/23/2018

    5 star ratingGreat food Family loves this place. Great food and great service. Menu is varied and agrees with all tastes. They serve breakfast,... read more

    modan5776 Avatar
    modan5776
    10/14/2018

    5 star ratingMost diners on Long Island are decent, but somewhat skeevy in my opinion. This place calls itself a "diner" they... read more

    Rich M. Avatar
    Rich M.
    1/09/2019
  • 5 star ratingBest gyro this side of the Mediterranean. Stopped in for lunch and tried the lamb gyro...it was awesome and served... read more

    Janet I. Avatar
    Janet I.
    10/12/2016

    5 star ratingAWESOME! My husband and I just had a baby and rarely leave the house. The Greek island diner delivered two... read more

    Hayley A. Avatar
    Hayley A.
    10/19/2016

    5 star ratingLoved the food..the variety was great. Will be  going back for the different flavors.

    Sandra V. Avatar
    Sandra V.
    6/09/2016
  • 5 star ratingWell cooked, well managed Huge portions of well cooked Greek and eclectic diner fare. Friendly, efficient waitresses and managers. The gyros have enough lamb... read more

    dallasdr Avatar
    dallasdr
    7/04/2019

    5 star ratingFresh and delicious! I'm always happy with the freshness, quality ingredients and friendly people there. Can't say a bad thing.

    Laura M Avatar
    Laura M
    3/11/2019

    5 star ratingWOW WOW WOW. I went here last night and fell in love. My mom had been mentioning how good the... read more

    Nicole V. Avatar
    Nicole V.
    7/21/2018
  • 5 star ratingI have eaten here often food is terrific always fresh tonite server was Erin she was very attentive and went... read more

    Rich S. Avatar
    Rich S.
    12/06/2016

    5 star ratingGreat food made fresh ! Excellent food and caring staff and owners that make you fell like you are at a friends or relatives for... read more

    Eric W Avatar
    Eric W
    11/24/2019

    I really enjoy their food and service, fantastic area to where I live. The workers are always kind. Will... read more

    Dashaun Maxfield Avatar
    Dashaun Maxfield
    7/13/2020
  • 5 star ratingGreat local Greek diner in Wading River.
    We end up here often when life makes it too busy to cook.
    Great...
    read more

    George P. Avatar
    George P.
    1/23/2018

    5 star ratingThis is our new favorite! Great staff awesome food. Must try! I always seem to order too much
    Potato skins are...
    read more

    Tanya Z. Avatar
    Tanya Z.
    4/29/2018

    5 star ratingBreakfast was awesome.chunky monkey pancakes were outstanding as well as the pumpkin pancakes. Service was the best we've had in... read more

    Chris C. Avatar
    Chris C.
    10/22/2017